In the never-ending case of Carbs v. Fat, it's the New York Times Gina Kolata v. the Times' Gary Taubes, whom CJR calls "one of the most interesting health writers in the country. He is an exhaustive researcher, an astute critic of experimental methodology, a historian of science and influential polemicist. But he can’t catch a break from Kolata. This is awkward, because they both write for the same paper."